First Iteration: Original Plain Cheesecake
Most Popular: Caramel Apple Cheesecake
Most Fascinating Flavor: Nutty Irishman
Why is Mara's Cake & Bakery so proud of their cheesecake?
In 1984, Mara and Glenn Magley began their mom and pop bakery using a traditional family recipe. In hindsight, the cheesecake began it all for wholesale bakery and, eventually, our cafes.
What is cheesecake?
Cheesecake is a dessert consisting of a layer of sweetened soft cheese (we use real Philadelphia cream cheese), mixed with cream, sugar, eggs and flavorings (such as fruit or chocolate) and set in a graham-cracker-crumb crust or an Oreo-cookie-crumb crust for any chocolate flavored cheesecakes.
What other menu items go well with cheesecake?
We suggest trying one of our drip coffees. Or if you are a purveyor of flavor, try a shot of our freshly roasted espresso.
Original Cheesecake: A velvety combination of the finest cheeses, freshest creams and pure vanilla brought together to create an exceptionally light and creamy cheesecake.
Snickers: We start with our original country cheesecake and mix in plentiful amounts of chopped Snickers. Topped with a layer of chocolate ganache and more Snickers pieces.
Wildberry: We mix a generous amount of raspberries, blueberries and blackberries into our original country cheesecake and bake it in our graham cracker crust.
Oreo: Oreo pieces throughout our original country cheesecake with Oreo ganache topping. Baked in an Oreo cookie crust.
Chocolate Swirl: We start with a rich, smooth, pure all natural chocolate and blend it with our original country cheesecake. Baked on a chocolate cookie crust.
Chocolate Chip: Our original country cheesecake loaded with mini chocolate chips. Baked on a cookie crust and topped with more chocolate chips.
Almond Brownie: Our original country cheesecake baked atop a rich chocolate cookie crust with brownie pieces throughout. Topped with more brownie pieces, chocolate ganache and toasted almond slices.
Butterfinger: Butterfinger pieces throughout our original country cheesecake with a ganache and Butterfinger topping. Baked on a chocolate cookie crust.
Chocolate Dipped Strawberry: Our original country cheesecake with a layer of fresh strawberry topping covered in our special and unique Belgian magic shell chocolate ganache. Baked on our chocolate cookie crust.
Caramel Apple Streusel: Our delicious cinnamon apple cheesecake topped with streusel crumb and drizzled with the perfect amount of luscious caramel.
Cookie Dough: Our delicious chocolate chip cookie dough blended into our original country cheesecake baked on a chocolate cookie crust. Topped with ganache and chocolate chip cookie pieces.